Where We Are Now

by Bedford Hope on January 19, 2014

27970.0.browse-m

I have taken a step or two back from this blog for a number of reasons. My wife and son have never been crazy about it, but as a writer, they gave me the space to write about this, under this pseudonym, and so far there have been no repercussions. We’ve turned down the offers for documentaries and reality television series; we’re not that kind of a family as it turns out, not that I’m in anyway passing judgement on families that do such things.

My son, mid-way through high-school, is again out as whatever-it-is-he-is; and I use that term as one of respect because he has not, and never has, used any term for himself but boy or girl. As in, “I’m a cute boy.” or “I’m a cute girl.” Said ironically, but not, because he is very pretty, and he works hard at being pretty; his primary interests now being hair, styling and coloring, makeup, fashion (what he can do with fashion with thrift store purchases and a part time job teaching after school.) and drawing manga characters that embody his fashion ideals.

Oscar’s manga heroes seldom smile; they look pensive, or downright disgusted. He started drawing males, for the first time ever, a few years back, and seems to draw them most frequently, now. They’re stylized in certain ways, with huge eyebrows, wide noses; they’re beautiful, too, like him, and also offbeat.

Now when I say that he’s out, I mean that he wears skirts, dresses, makeup, platform shoes. He has a strange fascination with the Spice Girls, which is of course, retro, as they’ve not been popular for a long long time.

“It’s all about the shoes,” he tells me.

His friends and activities take him all over the city on mass-transit. He’s in no hurry to grow up, go to clubs, drink and party, though he does have a fair amount of freedom and I suppose, at fifteen, we cannot know everything he is up to. He is not out in terms of preference. His relationship to gender is coy. Or, he’s simply gender queer, but isn’t interested in that word.

Whatever he is or will be is his business. I only have to love him and I do.

We’ve missed the window for any kind of intervention which might yield an invisibly MTF outcome; so far it all feels right. If in a  decade we’re helping pay tens of thousands of dollars for laser hair removal and trachea shaves and such, I suppose the ‘feeling right’ might one day turn out to be ‘feeling right but we were wrong.’ No one will ever be able to take away his height; about six feet at fifteen, he’ll always be tall.

All the drag queens I’ve met have been tall now that I think of it. I’m sure that’s a stupid generalization. Please let me know if it is.

So we are in our happy ending now, and this is why I write infrequently. That, and the fact that my son told me recently in no uncertain terms that this blog would never be a book. Heh.

But a recent comment from a reader said that he wanted me to keep writing, that he thought it could be helpful, maybe, so here I am again.

Life goes on. Our gender, our preference, these are big parts of us, but they are really just a smallish part of the totality of being human, or they could be, if we all got over ourselves and let each other simply be; I’m sure of this now. If you love your child as a straight and cis-gendered, you’ll love them as gay and trans, or any possible combination thereof, if you only let yourself. Will there be unpleasant moments? Confusion? Pangs of strange emotion? You betcha. Will you get through it and find a new normal?

You will. I promise you from the bottom of my heart. You will.

{ 2 comments }

To the Unicorn’s Dad

by Bedford Hope on August 5, 2013

I got a note from a kid who just came out as Trans, who asked for a post to his father. This is it. I hope it is useful.

Dear Father of an Exceptional Child,

You don’t know me, and I don’t know you, but first of all, I’m very glad that you didn’t freak out when your child revealed that he was transgender. The child you’ve known as she since birth told you he’s a he.

You didn’t kick your kid out of the house. You didn’t seem to have any reaction at all. Not a bad start.

We’re in very different boats, because my  child was born a boy, and when a boy insists on wearing girl clothes, liking girl characters, well. It’s obvious something is afoot. We had a lot of time to figure this out, over the years.

You haven’t. The rules are different, for boys and girls, and the culture prepares us better for girls who like boy things. Nothing wrong with that, but it probably means that you were blind sided. We had years to come to terms with this. Years and years. You’ve had a few weeks.

First of all, you need to reach out, yourself, for support, in the form of some of the groups in my sidebar. Some are in person, some are on-line; however you do it, do it. You won’t realize how much you need it until you do it.

Do it.

Maybe you were preparing yourself for having a gay kid. I know we were. In my support community, we spend a lot of time, wondering, to ourselves, out of earshot of our children, ‘gay, trans, gender queer, cross dresser, or just-a-phase?’

There aren’t many ‘just-a-phases.’ This stuff means something, something important, in almost all cases. But you’re not a clinician, you’re not playing the numbers, you have one kid.

Your kid is reaching for professional support, professional input, and I hope that you can help him get it. Someone who has experience with transgender. We know, in my community, from past experience, that not all professionals are up to this, however. There may be no one in your health plan; no one in your city. But look hard. Monitor the treatment carefully, and be prepared to find someone new if the first person you find stinks.

Trans Youth Family Advocates (see the links in my sidebar) is a great place to start. The story of Kim Pearson and her son is one that will feel familiar to you. Her son is a transman. He’s a great kid, I’ve met him, though he’s not really a kid anymore.

Growing up, her kid was accepted and celebrated in all her interests, playing on the boy’s baseball team, her hair and clothing choices respected, by a family that was utterly and completely shocked by the transgender revelation. Within a matter of weeks, they’d educated themselves and figured out a plan. The plan changed, over time, as all plans do. But they were up to it, and so are you.

Her child, who had been afraid to order for himself in fast food restaurants, who had hidden himself under layer upon layer of clothing even in the stifling heat of the Arizona summer, came into his own through the therapy. Life got better for him, for them.

You’re going to ask yourself—did we do this, somehow? Is our kid the way our kid is, because of how we raised him? Because we ‘indulged’ his interests? Because we didn’t force him into dresses? We didn’t force him to have more friends and activities within his bio-gender?

You’re going to ask these things even as your research shows you, no, you didn’t cause this; this is just one of ways people are.

You’re going to ask yourself this; so listen to me when I tell you, you didn’t do this to your kid, this isn’t a result of trauma or parenting or high power lines or MSNBC or Rachel Madow or Ellen or Chaz Bono.

This is one of ways people are, one of the ways people have always been; you can’t stamp this out of people. We know this because we all tried to, at one point or another, to one degree or another. There isn’t a parent I’ve met who didn’t play gender police for some period of time. Some of the parents in our support group went whole hog, Zuckering their kds.

Zucker is a former gay reparationist, a psychologist who believes he can with therapy avert transexual outcomes. In his small sample he seems to have succeeded; with the one small caveat, that none of his patients report being happy after treatment.

And there lies the core of it. You want your kid to be happy, and you worry, that if your kid is like this, they won’t be. And so you wonder, if there is something to be done to change it. We all went through this.

We found out two things.

One, our kids can be happy. It’s not a sure thing; happiness never is, but in our support group we see a lot of success stories; enough to know that being transgender doesn’t mean you can’t be happy and successful.

Two, the other thing, is you can’t change this. It lies at the core of identity. Exactly what this is, your kid may not yet fully understand, and professional help can help you get to the core of things. But there are no widely respected professionals at this point who seriously think they can alter someones gender identity or preference.

Gender identity is more controversial and than sexual preference. The culture is making huge strides in acceptance of gays and lesbians, and crawling much slower in its understanding of transgender. Confusion exists with the Gay and Lesbian community on what exactly Trans is, so you may face opposition from places you expected support. Keep looking, though, support is out there.

Mostly, I want to say, that weird visceral feelings of discomfort, shame, remose, anger, fear, fade over time and are replaced by love, acceptance, admiration, and a new normal, which includes your child and your child’s friends and significant others.

You’ve joined another family. Whether you want it or not. Some trans folk like to transition and return to normal; people like Chaz Bono who don’t really see themselves as Transmen. They’re just men. Men born with a birth defect.

Some trans people remain under the GLBTQ umbrella, comfortable with the support and understanding that often resides there. There’s no one right way to be transgender. No single understanding of gender we all agree on intuitively. And that’s OK; as long as we listen, and respect each other, we can all get along, as our understandings deepen.

Be glad your kid knows now. Be glad your kid trusted you enough to tell you. Be glad you didn’t freak out.

Reach out for support, for you and your kid; nobody can do this alone.

It’s going to be OK. You’re going to be Ok.

Welcome to the family, to the movement, to this imperfect moment in time and your own imperfect state of being. It gets better, as Dan Savage says. It really does. I promise.

Bedford Hope

(AKA Accepting Dad.)

{ 5 comments }

Kickstarter OUT Youth Theater Project Tells A New Story

April 5, 2013

This documentary film moves beyond the boilerplate feel-good progressive boosterism by capturing the voices of the kids themselves. Who are these young people? What is their experience? Where are we really, in this moment in time? Where are we all in this journey? Why not spend some time with these young people, their friends and […]

Read the full article →

Be A Man

March 7, 2013

We must be swift as a coursing river BE A MAN With all the force of a great typhoon BE A MAN With all the strength of a raging fire Mysterious as the dark side of the moon –Mulan, 1998, Walt Disney Pictures We’re re-watching the Disney canon with Oscar, at his insistence, and enjoying […]

Read the full article →

Girl Things: Accepting Dad in Convenient Book Form

February 27, 2013

I am editing Accepting Dad into a book titled Girl Things. The book will feature revised (and copyedited, finally) content from the blog arranged so as to tell a chronological story, with several additional essays included. I will be pulling most of the blog content contained in Girl Things, with the exception of a sample […]

Read the full article →

REVIEW: Gender Born, Gender Made by Diane Ehrensaft, Ph.D.

June 17, 2011

The cover of my review copy of Dr. Diane Ehrensaft’s new book, Gender Born, Gender Made might have been made from one of my family’s snapshots. The presumably male-bodied toddler with the tutu worn over his pants peers quizzically into the camera’s eye, evoking a shiver of recognition. I know that kid. He could have […]

Read the full article →

New Study Confirms Supportive Parenting Does Not Hurt Gender Non-Conforming Children

January 12, 2010

I’ve had the opportunity to read a draft of a recent study by Hill, D.B., Menvielle, E., Sica, K.M., &  Johnson, A. (2010), of children in different therapeutic environments published in The Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy shows that supportive / accepting parenting is associated with lower rates of mental illness. From the abstract: When […]

Read the full article →

The Tomgirl Profile: Commonalities among gender-variant or gender non-conforming boys

September 29, 2009

As supportive parents find each other through mailing lists on the internet (see the CNMC and Transkidsfamily) we share stories about our kids, and the problems they face— and the problems we face being thier parents. Over the years a profile builds up, qualities that many of these boys seem to share. We are astonished […]

Read the full article →

Open Letter to KRXQ 98.5 FM Sacremento

September 22, 2009

KRXQ transgender kid controversey: After an ugly and defamatory broadcast which suggested that child abuse was a good response to gender-non-conformity, and a wide-spread community reaction,  a group of sponsors pulled support from the station, triggering both an apology and a follow up broadcast which became a teachable moment for the community. Some in the community […]

Read the full article →